Status: Proposed. An application or option exists. Nothing has been decided.
Hamilton committee backs heritage designation for the Mills, Oak Hall and Woolworths buildings at King and James as a three-tower redevelopment is explored
Planning Committee voted to move toward designating five downtown Hamilton properties at King Street East and James Street North. A June 2026 pre-application proposes demolishing most of them for three towers with 1,205 homes.
The details
What the committee decided
Hamilton's Planning Committee voted 7 to 0 on September 29, 2026, to approve recommendations from the Hamilton Municipal Heritage Committee directing the City Clerk to give notice of Council's intention to designate two groups of downtown properties under Part IV of the Ontario Heritage Act, according to the committee's minutes.
- 11-15 King Street East (former Mills Department Store), 10-12 James Street North (former Oak Hall) and 14 James Street North (former Mills Hardware Store), built from 1899 to 1903.
- 17 and 19-31 King Street East (former Woolworths Building), a row of three-storey, stone-fronted commercial buildings built in 1949.
If no objections are received after the notices, staff are to bring designation by-laws to Council; if an objection is received, staff are to report back so Council can decide whether to withdraw the notice.
The redevelopment idea
Both staff reports say the City received Formal Consultation application FC-2026-00135 in June 2026. It contemplates assembling 1-9 King Street East, 13-41 King Street East, 16-26 James Street North and 38 King William Street, demolishing the heritage buildings at 1-9, 13-31 and 17 King Street East, and keeping the south facade and part of the east facade of 35-41 King Street East within a three-tower, mixed-use development.
- 1,205
- About 1,955 square metres
- 1,053
- Formal consultation only; no development application received as of the reports
Heritage staff said in their comments on the pre-application that they strongly encouraged retaining and integrating the heritage buildings, and that a Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment would be needed with any future application.
Why staff say the buildings matter
Staff found the Mills and Oak Hall properties to be early twentieth-century commercial buildings combining Victorian and Edwardian influences, with Oak Hall a representative example of Romanesque Revival-influenced commercial architecture. They tie the buildings to the Mills family's department and hardware stores and to Oak Hall's role as a flagship store of Senator William Eli Sanford (1834–1899), whose Sanford Manufacturing Company the report calls the first and largest maker of ready-made clothing in Canada.
The Woolworths row was found to be a representative example of Art Deco-influenced commercial buildings, associated with the F. W. Woolworth Company, Hamilton architect W. Bruce Riddell and the Hamilton Bridge Works Company. Staff said it met seven of the nine provincial criteria and helps define the historic commercial character of King Street East and Gore Park.
Before the committee vote, staff met E.R.A. Architects on September 21 and revised the lists of heritage attributes for both reports, after the heritage committee directed them to work with Aragon Development Corporation and E.R.A. Architects Inc. to address their concerns. Planning Committee adopted the revised versions.
Update, November 10: City publishes the formal notice of intention to designate
Update, November 10: On November 9, 2026, the City Clerk published a public notice of the City's intention to designate the two groups of properties — 17 and 19-31 King Street East (the former Woolworths Building), and 11-15 King Street East, 10-12 James Street North and 14 James Street North (the former Mills Department Store, Oak Hall and former Mills Hardware Store) — under Section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act as being of cultural heritage value. The notice says any person may, within 30 days after the November 9 publication, serve a written notice of objection on the City Clerk at the Office of the City Clerk, 71 Main Street West; counted from that date the window ends about December 9, though the Clerk's office is the authority on how it is calculated, and the properties are proposed for designation, not yet designated.
Sources
City of Hamilton
Planning Committee Minutes PLC 26-013, September 29, 2026City of Hamilton
Intention to Designate Properties in Hamilton