Hamilton's Auditor General found systemic fairness problems in the City's HR workplace investigations in an audit released August 6, 2026
An audit released on August 6, 2026 found widespread procedural fairness concerns in the City of Hamilton's human resources investigations and a 76 per cent substantiation rate in the files sampled. Management accepted all six recommendations.
The details
What the audit found
On August 6, 2026, the City of Hamilton's Office of the Auditor General released its audit of the City's Human Resources Investigations Process. The audit set out to assess how far the process reflects accepted standards for workplace investigations in Ontario and whether the problems it observed were systemic.
According to the Auditor General's release, the office found widespread procedural fairness concerns across the sample of files it reviewed, and concluded that the findings suggest systemic weakness in both the City's investigation framework and its overall processes. It also identified indicators suggesting a lack of neutrality in investigations.
One figure stands out. In the sample, 76 per cent of complainants' allegations were found to be substantiated. The audit called that rate unusually high compared with the typical ranges cited in workplace investigation research, and said it raised concerns that complainant evidence may in some cases have been accepted with insufficient scrutiny.
- August 6, 2026
- City of Hamilton Office of the Auditor General
- 76 per cent
- 6, all accepted by management
- A 2024 Fraud and Waste Hotline report; audit launched in late 2025
- January 2027
How it started
The audit was not on a regular schedule. The Auditor General launched it in late 2025 as what the office calls a spontaneous value-for-money audit, after a Fraud and Waste Hotline report received and investigated in 2024 raised concerns about how HR investigations were being run. City Council's August 5, 2026 agenda, the day before the public release, listed the audit as a closed-session item, report AUD26006(a), citing the provisions for personal matters about identifiable individuals and solicitor-client advice.
How the City responded
In a statement issued the same day, the City said the audit identified longstanding and significant gaps in its workplace investigation processes, and that complainants and respondents both deserve a process that is fair, impartial and consistent. It said management had accepted all six recommendations and had begun implementing corrective measures:
- Targeted, strengthened training for Human Resources investigation staff.
- Enhanced oversight and review of investigation reports before they are finalized.
- Updated procedural templates to make practice consistent across investigations.
- Strengthened supervisory oversight of the investigations process as a whole.
What the releases do not say
Neither release states how many files were sampled, what period they cover, or whether any past investigation outcomes will be reopened or reviewed in light of the findings. The six recommendations are not listed individually in the releases.
Where it stands now
The City's commitment is that staff will report back to Council in January 2027 on full implementation of the recommendations. HamiltonIQ checked the City's news releases on November 9, 2026, and found no further statement on the audit since August 6. The City's Fraud and Waste Hotline, the channel that prompted the audit, operates 24 hours a day.